Live Chat
Sex Toys
Popular Searches
Rabbit Vibrators Clitoral Suction Vibrators Magic Wand Vibrators Clitoral VibratorsTrending Products
Your Basket
Subtotal:
Gay Butt Plugs
We are the sexual happiness people and we are proud to make a fun and fulfilling sex life available to everyone. If you’re looking for a vibrator, a dildo, a flashlight , a cock ring, sex toys for couples or anything else, our huge range of sex toys is guaranteed to satisfy.
When you shop at Sweetypy you’ll enjoy free delivery on all orders over $94.00, free returns, 24/7 customer care, expert advice and over 100,000 sex toy reviews.
Filter Options
Department
Brand
Price
Size
Colour
Material
Customer Rating
Seller
See more
Shop With Confidence
Enjoy Free UK Delivery on all orders above €50 with Royal Mail Tracked 48. 100% discreet, boxed & plain packaging. 30 Day returns & 1 year warranty on all sex toys
10% off
ANAL FANTASY OPEN WIDE BLACK TUNNEL PLUG Advanced Anchors Large Butt Plug Gay Sex Toys, Silicone Large Butt Plug Gay Sex Toys
You save: $3.76 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Black Silicone Prostate Exerciser, Anal Dildo Vibrator Butt Plug Gay Prostate Massager
You save: $3.35 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 7 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Njoy Pure Fun Plug Stainless Steel PSpot Metal Dildo Butt Plug, Beginners Anal Silver Metal Waterproff Classic Butt Plug, Gay Anal Prostate Bondage Sex Toys
You save: $35.51 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
Pride Pleasure Plug Rainbow Small
You save: $5.85 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 8 left in stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
Aneros Eupho Trident Prostate Massager, Beginners Anal Dildo Vibrators, Male Prostate Massagers Butt Plug
You save: $15.87 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 8 left in stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
ToyJoy Smooth Investigator Black Anal Dildos, Beginners Anal Sex Toys With Prostate Massagers
You save: $2.92 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 6 left in stock.
10% off
Dorcel Diamond Butt Plug Rose Gold Large
You save: $6.68 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
TOYJOY ANAL PLAY BUBBLE BUTT PLAYER PRO BLACK Gay Classic Butt Plug Bondage Sex Toys, Silicone Male Prostate Classic Butt Plug Gay Sex Toys for Beginners
You save: $3.35 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 15 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Rocks Off Teazer Petite Sensations Purple Butt Plug, Beginners Anal Vibrators Sex Toys, Gay Vibrating Butt Plug, Ribbed Butt Plug, Beginners Anal Vibrators Sex Toys
You save: $4.17 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 6 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Perfect Fit Double Tunnel XLarge Butt Plug, Anal Advanced Butt Plug for Intense Stimulation
You save: $12.32 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 8 left in stock.
10% off
Glams Silicone Rainbow Gem Jeweled Butt Plug, Classic Beginners Black Anal Jeweled Butt Plugs, Gay Anal Sex Toys
You save: $5.02 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 14 left in stock.
10% off
Master Series Dark Stopper Metal And Silicone Anal Butt Plug, Beginners Classic Metal Butt Plug Bondage Male Prostate Toys, Gay Anal Sex Toys
You save: $10.02 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
Large Metal Anal Plug With Clear Crystal
You save: $3.35 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 5 left in stock.
10% off
Master Series Clenched Fist Dildo, Large Non Realistic Fisting Dildos for Gay Anal Sex Toys and Gay Butt Plugs
You save: $17.13 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 10 left in stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
FireFly Prince Butt Plug Small
You save: $2.71 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 6 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Icicles No.75 Pink Heart Glass Butt Plug, Beginners Jeweled Classic Glass Butt Plug, Gay Anal Sex Toys
You save: $6.05 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 11 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Power Gem Butt Plug Vibrating Crystal Probe, Beginners Silicone Purple Waterproof Anal Dildos Vibrating Butt Plug, Male Prostate Massagers Gay Anal Sex Toys
You save: $8.99 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Renegade P Spot Kit
You save: $6.68 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 10 left in stock.
10% off
PipeDream Pink Glass DILDO, ICICLES NO. 24 GLASS DILDO, BUTT PLUG ANAL DILDO, GAY ANAL SEX TOYS
You save: $13.78 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
Fantasy CRingz Rock Hard AssGasm Prostate Massager, Anal Cock Rings and Vibrating Butt Plugs for Gay Male Prostate Massagers and Anal Dildos
You save: $7.93 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 7 left in stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
You2Toys Red Push Classic Vibrators, Skin Safe Rubber Classic and Penis Vibrators
You save: $9.81 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 6 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Gleaming Butt Plug Set Rose Gold
You save: $7.52 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 5 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Evolved Vibrating Butt Plug Metal Plug, Beginners Silver Anal Dildos Vibrating Butt Plug, Male Prostate Massagers Gay Anal Sex Toys
You save: $11.90 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 15 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Hardastic Super Mike Huge Dildo
You save: $14.20 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 7 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Large Red Jewelled Silicone Butt Plug, Classic Beginners Anal Jeweled Butt Plugs, Gay Anal Sex Toys
You save: $2.71 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 15 left in stock.
10% off
Aneros Progasm Ice Anal Prostate Butt Plug, Clear Plastic Butt Plug Massager
You save: $18.18 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 8 left in stock.
10% off
ToyJoy Anal Play Bum Buster Prostate Massager Black, Anal Dildos Vibrators, Beginners Butt Plug, Male Prostate Massagers Toys
You save: $2.09 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 10 left in stock.
10% off
Playhouse 7 Inch Pleasure Steel Butt Plug Dildo, Stainess Steel Silver Butt Plug
You save: $11.28 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
Dorcel Medium Geisha Anal Plug Ruby, Beginners Butt Plugs, Jeweled Butt Plug, Gay Butt Plugs
You save: $8.14 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 14 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Perfect Fit Armour Tug Lock Anal Cock Rings Black Medium, Silicone Butt Plugs Anal Cock Rings Gay Sex Toys
You save: $10.02 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 8 left in stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
Icicles No.79 Pink Crystal Glass Butt Plug, Beginners Jeweled Classic Glass Butt Plug, Gay Anal Sex Toys
You save: $6.05 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 6 left in stock.
10% off
FemmeFunn Vortex Wireless Turbo Penis Vibrators, Black Large Couples Dildos & Penis Vibrators
You save: $27.36 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 14 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
XL SILICONE Anal Anchors Gay INFLATABLE BUTT PLUG Bondage Sex Toys, Black Male Prostate Inflatable Butt Plug Gay Sex Toys for Beginners
You save: $9.61 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
BEGINNERS SIZE SLIM BUTT PLUG RED Anal Gay Classic Butt Plug Bondage Sex Toys, Silicone Male Prostate Classic Butt Plug Gay Sex Toys for Beginners
You save: $2.29 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 6 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Anal Fantasy Insta Gaper Butt Plug
You save: $5.64 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Red Heart Shaped Jeweled Anal Plug, Small Butt Plug for Enhanced Sensations and Pleasure
You save: $1.88 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 5 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
XR The Black Destroyer Huge Suction Cup Dildo
You save: $25.27 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 13 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Renegade Bull Premium Silicone Butt Plug, Anal Dildos for Beginners and Gay Prostate Massagers
You save: $7.93 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 10 left in stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
Nexus Ride Extreme Prostate Massager for Gay Anal Sex Toys and Male Prostate Massagers
You save: $19.84 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 8 left in stock.
10% off
GLASS DILDO WITH BLUE SPIRAL DESIGN, Waterproof Blue Anal GLASS DILDO, Butt Plug Anal Dildo, Gay Anal Sex Toys
You save: $3.14 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 8 left in stock.
10% off
Aneros Maximus Trident Prostate Massager,Butt Plugs Anal Dildos Male Prostate Massagers Toys
You save: $16.08 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 6 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Anal Fantasy Mega Glass Butt Plug Anal Gaper, Beginners Jeweled Glass Butt Plug, Gay Anal Sex Toys
You save: $7.52 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 10 left in stock.
10% off
Master Series Gape Glory Hollow Anal Plug
You save: $4.80 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 11 left in stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
Nexus Simul8 Butt Plug, Dual Butt Plug and Cock and Ball Toy, Black Silicone Butt Plug
You save: $17.13 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 10 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Renegade Peekers Trainer Hollow Butt Plug Kit
You save: $7.93 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Glams Silicone Rainbow Gem Butt Plug Pink
You save: $5.02 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 10 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Master Series Peephole Hollow Anal Glass Butt Plug, Beginners Glass Butt Plug, Gay Anal Sex Toys
You save: $4.80 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 12 left in stock.
10% off
Black Penis Anal Classic Couples G Spot Gay Butt Plugs Cheap Vibrators, Plastic Realistic Vibrating Dildos Cheap Vibrators
You save: $3.14 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
White Nights 7 Inch Ribbed Anal Vibrator
You save: $5.64 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 7 left in stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
COLT WEIGHTED PLUMPER Gay INFLATABLE BUTT PLUG Sex Toys, Silicone Black Anal Anchors Inflatable Butt Plug Gay Sex Toys
You save: $8.99 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 12 left in stock.
10% off
Fantasstic Vibrating Anal Anchor Plug
You save: $3.35 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Love To Love Remote Control Double Stimulator Love Eggs, Wonderlove Anal Vibrating Love Eggs Sex Toys
You save: $21.94 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 9 left in stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
Mood Naughty 1 Butt Plug Trainer Set
You save: $7.73 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
Oxballs Cocksling 2 With Attached Buttballs, Ribbed Butt Plug for Gay Anal Sex Toys and Male Prostate Toys
You save: $26.32 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
MOJO SPADES LARGE BLACK Anal Gay Classic BUTT PLUG Bondage Sex Toys, Silicone Large Classic Butt Plug Gay Sex Toys for Beginners
You save: $2.29 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
Dr. Joel Kaplan Perineum Massager 4.5
You save: $3.35 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 11 left in stock.
10% off
Rocks Off Plug Petite Sensations Black Butt Plug
You save: $3.76 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 15 left in stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
APlay Shaker Silicone Anal Plug with Remote
You save: $20.68 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 5 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
ToyJoy The Manhandler 14.5 Inch Flesh Pink
You save: $5.64 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 6 left in stock.
10% off
3 Piece Silicone Anal Probe Kit
You save: $6.05 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 8 left in stock.
10% off
Mini Butt Plug With Finger Hole Blue
You save: $1.04 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 6 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Inflatable And Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug
You save: $6.26 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
INYA Spades Small Purple Butt Plug, Beginners Anal Sex Toys and Classic Butt Plug for Beginners
You save: $3.76 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
SILEXD PREMIUM SILICONE MEDIUM Anal Gay Classic BUTT PLUG Bondage Sex Toys, Black Male Prostate Classic Butt Plug Gay Sex Toys for Beginners
You save: $5.43 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 5 left in stock.
10% off
Hurry, low stock
Nexus GPlay Rechargeable Prostate Massager Med
You save: $8.35 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 10 left in stock.
10% off
Dorcel Expert P Size Small Prostate Plug for Beginners Anal Sex Toys and Male Prostate Massagers
You save: $11.07 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 9 left in stock.
10% off
Pride Pleasure Plug Rainbow Medium, Beginners Anal Butt Plug, Gay Butt Plugs, Beginners Anal Butt Plug
You save: $7.31 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 5 left in stock.
10% off
Rouge Stainless Steel Anal Hook Metal Butt Plug, Silver Metal Butt Plug, Gay Anal Sex Toys
You save: $8.56 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 10 left in stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Playhouse Flow And Bulb Pleasure Steel Butt Plug Wand, Stainess Steel Silver Butt Plug
You save: $11.28 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
No Stock.
10% off
Selling Fast - Buy Now
Alien Dildo with Suction Cup Type I
You save: $6.90 (10%)
FREE delivery Monday 28th
Or fastest delivery Tomorrow
Only 9 left in stock.
Gay Anal Sex ToysRecommended For You
Our top recommendation for you from top brands to give you the ultimate end.
Recently Viewed
Your recently viewed products. Check out other amazing toys here.
Discreet
packaging
100% Guaranteed discrete packaging. It’s a secret!
24/7 chat &
email support
Get in touch with us 24/7 chat and email support.
Get it next
day
Guaranteed next day delivery. TC conditions apply
100 day money back promise
on toys & bondage
Not satisfied. Contact us and we will take care of the rest.
Gay Butt Plugs
Learn more about gay butt plugs through our video guides and blogs.
When you shop at Sweetypy you’ll enjoy free delivery on all orders over $94.00, free returns, 24/7 customer care, expert advice and over 100,000 sex toy reviews.
Frequently Asked Questions
All your questions answered about buying Gay Butt Plugs
Ask Any Question
